The Stanford Daily

News





Comments about "Admins outline endowment spending"


<< Back to Admins outline endowment spending

4 Comments on this article:

Report as: spam offensive E=mcⁿ on 4/23/08 at 5am

Giving discounted tuition and room and board to the scholarly in need does not meet the legal requirement that 20.5 percent of the endowment fund is restricted for undergraduate and graduate scholarship. The money has to go out of the endowment fund each year and into student scholarship at the graduate and undergraduate level. You don't get to deduct this amount from general revenues. You are cheating the students by paying out with your accounting inflated dollars.

Giving to Stanford may be a good investment for alumni: Give a million and get three million back in RICO Act damages.

Report as: spam offensive what? on 4/23/08 at 8am

Your argument would be all fine and good if it weren't for the fact that 20% earnings is just an absurd figure to consider over the long-term. Spending has to be consistently sustainable, while ensuring that the endowment is growing to keep pace with inflation. Which is why universities, and indeed nearly all non-profit institutions, spend roughly 5% of endowment income per year (foundations are also subject to government mandates of spending 5% a year). Spending more than that is just plain reckless. It would be a violation of the trustee's mandate to maintain Stanford's economic stability for future generations. Even with Stanford's substantial financial resources, the endowment covers a mere 20% of total yearly operating expenses, which is low by the standards of peer universities. Harvard for instance supports 31% of yearly operations through its endowment, giving it much greater long-term sustainability. By the way, referring to this as "stupid reporting" along with your rather rudimentary (and incorrect) analysis of accounting, just demonstrates an appalling lack of basic financial and economic literacy. I suggest picking up a book that explains the concept of how an endowment is designed to work. I'm sure you could gain a better understanding of how these institutions are managed.

Report as: spam offensive what? on 4/23/08 at 8am

I should point out that this doesn't negate the need for increased financial aid. In fact, even with the programs currently offered, the university should go further in supporting undergraduate and graduate financial assistance. But that will only come from making aid a top priority even more so than it is, not from irrational arguments about how the endowment is managed.

Report as: spam offensive Eulenspiegel on 4/23/08 at 1pm

Some sort of smoothing is required to deal with fluctuations in the economy and the return on the endowment. But, instead of spending 5.5 or some such percentage, how about spending all endowment income for academic and scholarship purposes to the extent in exceeds the amount necessary to adjust capital for inflation. Even with a three or five or seven-year smoothing adjustment, that would result in much higher spending in recent periods.




(Comments are meant to provide a constructive way for users to interact online. Please keep discussion civil, and refrain from using profanity, personal attacks, potentially libelous language, or hate speech. The Stanford Daily is not responsible for any content that appears in the comment section of its Web site. The Daily is not responsible for monitoring the board or removing comments that could be in violation of the policy. The editors of the non-profit newspaper support a free exchange of ideas, even if beliefs expressed are controversial, but The Stanford Daily Publishing Corporation claims all rights and sole discretion to delete or not delete any post for any reason at any time. If something is posted in the comment section of the Web site, the expressed view should not be understood as an endorsement by The Daily or any of its agents. All comments must comply with the “Terms and Conditions For Use” as set out in the “About us” section of the Web site, or they may be removed. By posting a comment, you attest that the material is not copyrighted and that you are fully relinquishing all rights of ownership to said content exclusively to The Daily while maintaining full responsibility for what you write.)