Comments about "UPDATE: Brook Lopez academically ineligible for fall quarter"
<< Back to UPDATE: Brook Lopez academically ineligible for fall quarter
8 Comments on this article:
Wow, Stanford. This looks really, really bad. I doubt Lopez was taking a suite of rigorous classes, too, considering he lists Creative Writing as his major on Facebook. Too much doodling around with a silly basketball, drinking in the glory, not enough time putting imaginary thoughts, reveries and fantasies down on paper.
What a tremendous oaf.
Stanford should follow the University of Chicago's lead and get rid of school-sponsored athletics. President Hennessy recently called for an increased undergraduate population in an editorial in the Stanford Magazine. Too few deserving students are able to benefit from the quality of a Stanford education under the current arrangements, he argued. Instead of expanding the freshman class, let's stop admitting academically-unqualified athletes and give their seats to students who would take Stanford's academic program seriously.
While I agree that academically-unqualified athletes should not be admitted, it seems that this case is an anomaly. I have not previously heard of a player being academically ineligible (though I concede that this may have happened to a less high-profile player and thus been unpublicized). In general, the Stanford athletes I have met have been absolutely qualified to be in the classroom with us non-athletes. Some of them don't just fit in; they are downright amazing students. I am proud to have these people as my classmates.
Mr. Lopez obviously doesn't have any intention of earning a degree at Stanford. He is here to increase his earning power when he goes to the NBA. If you were not planning to finish a degree, you wouldn't work very hard on your studies, would you? This is a general problem with college basketball in the power conferences, as many top players are living a lie in which they pretend to be students when their minds are elsewhere. I think Stanford has to make a difficult choice about whether it wants to be rigorous in upholding academic standards, or whether it wants to compete with the best in high profile sports such as basketball. I agree that academically unqualified students should not be admitted into Stanford just to bounce a ball. And Stanford can do very well in many sports without admitting them. Basketball will be tough, but even there Mike Montgomery's 1998 team had a 30-5 record and a Final Four berth despite not having any players with as much raw talent as Brook Lopez. But we'll probably have to accept that we won't be winning men's basketball games against the likes of Duke, Arizona, and UCLA with our normal admissions requirements.
It also seems that things are not in good shape with the basketball team. Yes, Lopez deserves the blame for not performing well enough to be eligible. But I also see a general lack of discipline on the team since Trent Johnson took over in 2004. We lost Tim Morris to Washington after he became academically ineligible in 2005, and guess who was the coach when that happened. The academic problems are just one symptom of the overall lack of leadership from Trent. It's been bad decisions, poor judgment, and inconsistent execution and effort for the past few years. Mike Montgomery was about commitment and always giving your best. One of the advantages of coaching at an academically selective institution like Stanford is that the students tend to be more disciplined and committed to overachieving. Montgomery understood that and used it to his advantage. Trent Johnson obviously doesn't get it.
I just posted a long thread on this over at the story about the USC win, but I basically am having a hard time enjoying this unbelievable USC win after hearing about the Lopez ineligibility. It's not so much a glorious upset anymore over the "Towering Trojan" when one of our Twin Towers appears to be dumb, or at least unengaged, as rocks.
Maybe I'm off base here, but I find that athletic success at Stanford — maybe not at USC — but at Stanford, is sweet only in the context of academic success.
He should take easier classes, perhaps THE EASIEST classes. It should be obvious that he would not graduate, so it really doesn't matter which classes as long as he can pass them to remain eligible.
I really don't think anyone expected him to graduate from Stanford. And honestly, waiting that long to jump to the NBA would be a terrible decision. He could risk getting injured and then lose millions of dollars in guaranteed money from an NBA draft lottery pick contract. Look at what happened to Shaun Livingston. Now imagine if that had happened to him in college. He would have been screwed for his life. Now he's set with millions in his bank account.
I just hope he can give us two more solid years before jumping ship. Oh, and I don't mind using a couple of spots from the 1,600 or so freshmen admitted each year for world class athletes.

SMS
RSS feeds