Comments about "Messenger bags: The newest trend in bookbags may be bad news for your back"
<< Back to Messenger bags: The newest trend in bookbags may be bad news for your back
8 Comments on this article:
i want to get a messenger bag and after reading this article it showed me what i have to be awaire of and what i dont.i now know that messenger bags can be harmful, but only if you dont use them correctly.i think im goin to get the messenger bag i want but also keep a regular book bag handy.
tahnks lots!
A messenger bag is just a fancy-schmancy name for a PURSE. If you are a man, avoid this like the plague. But do not, under any circumstances get a rolling backpack. Those things are irritating, and a potential hazard. Just use a regular old backpack and quit whining. Lift some weights during your summer vacation and those books won't feel so heavy in the fall.
David, I'm sorry, you have no idea what you're talking about. Messenger bags were created for....ding ding ding, messengers. They were never purses. They're meant to be for riding bikes, primarily. Most backpacks are not designed for use while bent over on the handlebars. Messenger bags allow you to carry the weight high up on your back, which is the best place on a bike. It is unfortunate, however, that most cheap messenger bags designed for schoolkids can't really be worn this way. Like the article says, they get worn low, near the hip, rather than high on the back and strapped down tightly. Take a look at chromebags.com, which specializes in professional bike messenger bags.
If you're going to ride a bike more than you walk, wear a properly designed messenger bag. If you're going to walk, take a backpack or...*gulp* "rolling bookbag"...
It's always about how people use these products, not simply the products in a vacuum.
I think messenger bags are nice. I have one myself and used it; it did not give me any problems whatsoever however I prefer knapsacks simply because they carry more items than a messenger bag. I am not one for fashion trends so I would rather look like a nerd, than a cool person.
I've used a backpack my whole life up until this year. I used a messenger bag this past year, and I'm sad (now) to say I used it the wrong way (with the strap not crossing my back, but just hanging on the right shoulder). It made my right shoulder really tense and not as flexible as the other one. It also gave the right shoulder more muscle, but now my shoulders just feel uneven. It's weird, and I'm switching back to a normal backpack next year.
P.S. wheely backpacks can be a HUGE nuisance in school settings (especially at schools like mine with stairs), being that they get in everyone's way and crowd up halls
I bought a wheely backpack because regular backpacks get on my nerves and I'm a weakling. It's made a huge difference and I have to say that it does come in handy when I need to carry excess weight. I have a messenger bag but I'm scared of the health effects though.
I have used one for several years cycling and it is now my "regular" pack as well. They are designed for cycle messengers. You don't have to be a messenger to use one, but for pete's sake they aren't designed for walking around per se anymore than mountainbike shoes are designed for ballroom dancing. You don't see people trying to do the tango in bike shoes and complaining the cleats hurt their feet. Folks gotta stop co-opting what's functional and making it a fashion statement. I'm all for messenger bags -- tho was a time when if you saw someone with it you knew they are or were a rider, which kinda helped. Now it could just be some dude taking the train, ok, it's a free country but it amazes me how people misuse products and then get some doctor to say oh, yeh, they are unsafe, avoid them. If worn improperly anything is unsafe. Also different bags fit differently; upon trying a different messenger bag with a different thickness strap I got neck pain. Adjusted it for the difference. No more pain. Common sense folks. That, and get a bike if you're going to get a messenger bag.
One good point in the article:
"In addition, a problem arises also because a messenger bag is situated so low on a student’s waist that it’s usually against the butt.” Edell said. "
Correct. Go to NYC or some other big city and watch the bike messengers. They don't have them hanging on their butts. They fit right on the bike. Because that's what they are designed for.
I use mine riding in traffic on streets alongside cars, in the rain, and in the sleet and sometimes snow. I'm more concerned about my right leg which is a half inch shorter and my rebuilt shoulder from being hit by reckless drivers. A bent back from my messenger bag? I should be so lucky if that was my main concern. But the good doctor int he article hits the key point: The reason that's a worry for some is they wear the bags wrong. I guess being a bike rider wearing it properly comes naturally to me, because if I wore it wrong (bouncing off my posterior as he said) the darn thing would cause me to crash.
Like I said, get on a bike, even if you don't wanna take up riding, just try it once and you'll get an appreciation for proper messenger bag fit.

SMS
RSS feeds